In a followup to my earlier article, Racism at the Bat, which discussed the inherent hypocrisy and Racism exhibited by the NCAA in their decision to only label Native American mascots and symbols as hostile and abusive, I now bring you absolute proof that their policy is unjust, unfair, and uncalled for.
The original list which the NCAA distributed is supposedly an all inclusive list of those mascots which are hostile and abusive. Closer inspection, however, will reveal a very conspicious omission. Somehow San Diego State got left off the list! What a tragedy! But of course, it must be an honest mistake. Right? I mean, obviously since they call themselves the Aztecs and use a blatent caricature of a Native American leader, Montezuma, as their official mascot they are in clear violation just like all of the other schools. Surely this is simply an oversight on the part of the NCAA who just happened to miss the school. After all they are working to eliminate all of the mascots which reference Native Americans, because using native peoples as a mascot is wrong, hostile and abusive.
I mean, when you think about it there are a LOT of schools out there. Who has the time to look through all of their mascots? It isn’t as if the Chancellor of the NCAA Division I board of directors has any personal knowledge of San Diego State, right? Oh wait! He does! He is in fact President of San Diego State! What a shocking revelation! I’m absolutely astounded myself, this makes it look like Stephen Weber may have been unethical and kept his own University off of the list without the normal process of appeals that even Florida State had to go through. Was Chancellor Weber playing favorites?!?! Say it isn’t so!
The official story from the NCAA is that no “organized tribe” relating to the Aztecs could be found for comment. Oh, ok. Now it becomes clear. Obviously the issue here is that all of the schools on the list specifically refer to an existing tribe? Such as the following references to specific organized tribes?
- Alcorn State Braves
- Catawba College Indians
- Midwestern State Indians
- Bradley Braves
- Arkansas State Indians
- Chowan College Braves
- Louisiana-Monroe Indians
- McMurry Indians
- Newberry College Indians
- Indiana U.-Pennsylvania Indians
- William and Mary Tribe
Oh wait! Those mascots didn’t refer to an organized tribe either! Somehow they ended up on the list, yet the Aztecs, a people who were massacred by the Europeans, and the school’s official symbol, Montezuma the leader of the Aztecs when the Europeans began their conquest for Spain, stayed off.
Imagine that, a whole slew of schools get blackmailed by the NCAA under the pretense of “eliminating hostile and abusive” native american imagery, and then we go and find out that the Aztec Warriors mysteriously get left off of the list of schools to blackmail, somehow getting a pass when other schools are held to the fire. It’s time for the NCAA to drop the false pretenses they are using, and to end their assault on the self determination rights of Universities. Their racism, favoritism, and corruption has been exposed and it should be obvious to any who review the evidence that what they have done is nothing more than blackmail. It’s time to bring back Chief Illiniwek, the feathers of William and Mary, and to end the assault on North Dakota and every other school on the dreaded, yet mysteriously incomplete, list.
-Angry Midwesterner

March 2, 2007 at 3:27 pm
I am not remotely surprised to see this. If he get any members of the Illini to comment on your university’s mascot, then I’d like to meet them and possibly recruit them to star in a yet-to-be-written zombie movie.
Also, you’d think that the largest literate civilization to arise in the Western Hemisphere before Columbus might count as native Americans, but apparently they’re not.
Perhaps Joseph Smith was right and Mesoamerican civilizations were actually all the result of colonization by the lost tribe of Israel? And if that’s true, would that make Stephen Weber an anti-Semite?
March 2, 2007 at 3:30 pm
“if he get” -> “if he got”
*facepalm”
March 2, 2007 at 6:58 pm
While I agree with you, I should like to point out that Montezuma was leader of the Aztecs when the Spaniards (themselves Europeans) began their conquest of MEXICO (or whatever the locals called it then). Sorry for the caps, I would italicize, but don’t know if WordPress allows html in comments.
March 2, 2007 at 7:03 pm
Unless you’re implying that Mexico is not part of North America, or perhaps that there are no Mexicans in California with native blood, I don’t see any point what so ever.
March 3, 2007 at 6:05 pm
I see what happened. I misread a preposition. Long days these.
March 6, 2007 at 8:43 pm
This obviously stems from the fact that the Latin-American immigrant population of the United States is practically non-existant. There’s noone around to get offended!
…wait a second…
Also… “As I mentioned in my letter of January 3, 2003, the Aztecs are not a Native American or American Indian culture,”
Since when do those words mean “Native United States of American” or “United States of American Indian”?
April 16, 2007 at 7:59 am
[...] going to be able to partake in the big bucks of college sports fully anymore,” it was over. The NCAA is horridly inconsistent about application of their policies and I have a hard time discerning any rhyme or reason to what [...]
November 16, 2007 at 11:16 am
[...] It may have a low teaser rate or may be an affinity card with your favorite sports symbol on it (“The Chief”). You decide that you will send it in. It says your rate may be “as low as” 3%. [...]
February 20, 2008 at 3:45 pm
Alcon State Braves rules
May 5, 2008 at 10:45 am
Since apparently being a tribe that weren’t wiped out on AMERICAN soil excludes the Aztecs from a list of offensive names, perhaps we should start using Canadian tribe names? Bradley Winnipegs, anyone?
July 27, 2008 at 11:53 am
Mr Angry, I am trying to confirm your claim that Stephen Weber, Pres of San Diego State University was a member of the NCAA Board of Directors at the time the “Offensive Mascot” schools were blacklisted by the NCAA – some of us at W&M are still POed about losing our feathers and logo and have not given up. When I check Weber’s CV as posted by SDSU there is no mention of any NCAA position. When I checked [as best I could] the NCAA Board of Directors membership there was no listing for Stephen Weber or SDSU. What was/is your source of information about Weber and the NCAA Board – could SDSU and the NCAA both have expunged the records?